Free Courses
Free Videos                                      Free Articles

Science, Health, and Healing Encyclopedia

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Ali

 

 

Ali Oxygen Library
Ali Recipes

Ali SHH-Pedia

ADHD

Adrenals

Aging

Alcholism

Allergy

Anger

Anxiety Course

 

 

  Asthma

 

  Autism

 

  Autoimmune Disorders

  Autonomic System

 Bladder, Urinary

 

 BLOOD
 
 BONES

 

  BRAIN

 

 BREAST Health.diseases

Breathing for Healing

 

BONES, Joints, and Muscles

 

 

CANCER

Children's Readings

 

CardiovascularDisease

 

Cancer
Chemotherapy

Avastin
 

 

Cholesterol

Climate Chaos

Collagen Disorders

COLON

Current Topics

Cystitis

 

Dialysis

DIABETES & INSULIN Toxicity

PRE-DIABETES

 

EARS

Emotions

Energy Healing

 

Endocrine
 

 

Eyes

Estrogens

 

Ethics

Exercise

Fermentation

Foods

Gall BladderStones

Genetics

GERD

Gluten

GUT Evolution
 

Genetics

GUT

     Mouth
      Esophagus
      Stomach
      Small Intestine
      Colon
      Rectum and Anus

Healing

Healing Stories

Heart

Hepatitis

Herbs

 

History

Hormones

Immune System

 

Inflammation

Infections

INSULIN TOXICITY

Joints

Kidneys

Kitchen Matters

 

Lap Dog Journalists

Leukemia

LIVER

Lou Gehrig ALS

 

Lungs

Lyme Disease, Acute


Lyme Disease, Chronic

Lymphatic System

 

 

 

Memory

Mental Health

 

Metabolism

 

Microbiology

Minerals

Mouth

Multiple Sclerosis

 

MUSCLES

Nose

 

Nutrition

Obesity

 

Oxygen
Basic Course Advanced Course
Oxygen and Aging
Oxygen Therapeutics
Oxygen -Environment
Oxygen and 9/11
Oxygen Models of Diseases
Oxygen and Origin of Life

 

 Ovaries

Pancreas Pancreatitis

Parkinson's Disease

Philosophy of Healing

Poems Drone Democracy
Selected Poems

Polycystic Ovarian Synd

Poetry of Dr.Ali

Potassium

Progesterone

 

Rectum

Recipes

Respiratory System

 

ReproductiveSystem
 
 

SHH-Pedia

Sinusitis & Polyps

 

Skin

Sodium Salt

Spices

Spleen

Small Intestine

Stomach

 

  Stories of Soul's Sweat

 

Stress

Stroke

Throat

Thyroid

Tongue

Tonsil

 

Toxic Womb State

Pre-birth PTSD

 

Testosterone
 

 

Urinary System

 

Uterus

Video Seminars on Natural Healing

Viral Infections

Recent Videos

 
Store DVD/Books
   
  Water

War

Weight Loss

Yeast Syndromes

Zinc

 

 

 

 

Pelvic Examination

How Helpful? How Harmful?

Majid Ali, M.D.

In the United States, ovarian surgery for removal of ovarian cysts and hysterectomy is done more than twice as often as in European countries. Do these procedures save more lives in the U.S. than in Europe? The answer: No.

I received my diploma of Fellow of Royal College of Surgeons of England in 1968. I do pelvic examinations for my female patients for specific reasons. I do not do routine pelvic examination.

I find the use of pelvic ultrasound scans extremely helpful for evaluation of pelvic organs.

The practice of routine pelvic examination recommended by the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. The College admits that this view is not justified by available practice.

Most European doctors will agree with my position on this examination. Until recently, most American doctors would have said some derisive words about it. Fortunately this is changing. Consider the following words of Dr. Carolyn L. Westhoff, a gynecologist at Columbia University in New York; "Iím an American gynecologist, and thatís how we were trained. It took many years for me to ask, ĎWhy are we doing this?" (The New York Times April 30, 2013).

Now consider the following from the same Times article: "Dr. Westhoff is among an increasing number of experts now challenging the value of this time-honored practice, which is done as a matter of course when women come in for routine gynecological checkups or Pap smears.

"These experts say that for women who are well, a routine bimanual exam is not supported by medical evidence, increases the costs of medical care and discourages some women, especially adolescents, from seeking needed care.

"Moreover, the exam sometimes reveals benign conditions that lead to follow-up procedures, including surgery, that do not improve a womanís health but instead cause anxiety, lost time from work, potential complications and unnecessary costs.

Below is the full text of The New York Times article entitled "An Exam With Poor Results" published: on April 30, 2013:

In America, when a woman goes to her gynecologist, she is typically given a pelvic exam whether or not she has symptoms or concerns that might warrant one. Thatís one reason an estimated 63.4 million pelvic exams are performed annually in this country.

Now a growing number of experts are asking whether itís necessary to do so many.

"This is not the case in other countries that get better results without doing routine pelvic exams," Dr. Carolyn L. Westhoff, a gynecologist at Columbia University Medical Center, said in an interview.

"Iím an American gynecologist, and thatís how we were trained. It took many years for me to ask, ĎWhy are we doing this?í "

For most women, Pap smears are now recommended just once every three to five years ó and for some, not at all. No doubt many women would be delighted to skip the routine pelvic exam, too, which many find uncomfortable and embarrassing.

A woman undergoing the exam is bare below the waist. She lies on the examining table on her back with her knees bent and legs spread apart, her feet in stirrups and her buttocks near the end of the table. The doctor inserts a lubricated, gloved finger into her vagina and, with the other hand, presses down on her abdomen to check the shape and size of her uterus and ovaries.

Itís called a bimanual exam. Dr. Westhoff is among an increasing number of experts now challenging the value of this time-honored practice, which is done as a matter of course when women come in for routine gynecological checkups or Pap smears.

These experts say that for women who are well, a routine bimanual exam is not supported by medical evidence, increases the costs of medical care and discourages some women, especially adolescents, from seeking needed care.

Moreover, the exam sometimes reveals benign conditions that lead to follow-up procedures, including surgery, that do not improve a womanís health but instead cause anxiety, lost time from work, potential complications and unnecessary costs.

"The number of women who follow this unfortunate path each year is unknown but is likely sizable given the sheer number of pelvic examinations performed each year in the United States," Dr. George F. Sawaya wrote in the Archives of Internal Medicine in December 2011.

"In my experience as a practicing gynecologist, I frequently have had to take patients into the operating room because I found an enlargement during a bimanual pelvic exam," Dr. Sawaya, a professor of obstetrics at the University of California, San Francisco, said in an interview.

"I then follow up with a sonogram which shows a mass, but I canít tell what the mass is without surgical exploration. Yet nearly always itís benign."

Dr. Sawaya says itís time to change this practice, in which doctors "put patients in a perilous situation and then act like theyíre rescuing them." He admits that his position "wonít win any popularity contests, but Iím trying to do whatís right for patients."

Dr. Westhoff and colleagues wrote in January 2011 in The Journal of Womenís Health, "Frequent routine bimanual examinations may partly explain why U.S. rates of ovarian cystectomy and hysterectomy are more than twice as high as rates in European countries, where the use of the pelvic examination is limited to symptomatic women."

She and others say that the justifications gynecologists typically offer for doing the pelvic exam ó screening for a sexually transmitted infection and cervical cancer, early detection of ovarian cancer, and evaluating a woman for hormonal contraception ó either do not require a bimanual exam or are not supported by research.

In a multicenter trial supported by the National Cancer Institute, for instance, no cancers of the ovaries were detected by a pelvic examination alone. The test sometimes did produce suspicious findings that resulted in further procedures.

"The pelvic examination is not an effective screening tool for ovarian cancer," Ms. Analia Stormo, a researcher at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and colleagues wrote last March in the journal Preventive Medicine.

Yet Ms. Stormo also found that "almost 70 percent of obstetrician-gynecologists reported believing that a pelvic examination is an effective means of screening for ovarian cancer."

To screen for sexually transmitted Chlamydia and gonorrhea, tests done on a urine sample or vaginal swab obtained by the patient "have numerous advantages" over the pelvic exam, Ms. Stormo and colleagues noted.

Although a pelvic exam has been traditionally coupled with prescriptions for contraception, both the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists and the World Health Organization have said that hormonal contraceptives like the birth control pill can be prescribed without first doing a pelvic exam.

"Whenever doctors are doing things by rote, we have to rethink whether what theyíre doing is really helpful," Dr. Sawaya said.

Dr. Westhoff concurs: "We should limit the well-woman checkup to proven procedures."

That is likely to be an uphill battle. Recent surveys by Dr. Sawaya and colleagues, among others, have shown that most gynecologists in the United States consider the routine bimanual exam of internal reproductive organs an important part of a well-woman visit. The practice is endorsed by the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, which nonetheless admits that medical evidence to justify it is lacking.

In the latest study, published online in November in the collegeís journal, Jillian T. Henderson, an assistant professor of obstetrics at the University of California, San Francisco, Dr. Sawaya and colleagues examined the circumstances under which a national sample of obstetrician-gynecologists would conduct a bimanual pelvic exam. The doctors were presented four vignettes about healthy patients, ages 18, 35, 55 and 70, who come "for a routine health visit."

Nearly all 250 doctors who took the survey said they "would conduct bimanual pelvic examinations in routine visits with asymptomatic women across the life span," even in a 55-year-old woman described as having no ovaries, uterus or cervix.

Most of the clinicians surveyed said the exam was important to identify benign uterine fibroids, even though the value of this finding in women lacking symptoms is unclear, the team reported. Most clinicians also maintained that the pelvic exam was important "to reassure patients of their health."

How important is this exam to a doctorís income? Slightly more than half of those surveyed ranked "ensuring adequate compensation" as very important or moderately important.

One of the most vexing problems in medicine today is the fact that doctors get paid only for performing procedures, not for the time they spend talking with patients to discuss issues of possible medical importance.

The next time you see your gynecologist for a routine checkup, ask if a pelvic exam is planned and, if so, what the doctor expects it to accomplish.

Related Articles

* The Reproductive System

* Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome (PCOS)

* Sex Hormone Health-Five-Dimensional Hormone-Thinking

* PCOS - Taking It On the Ovaries (TOCS)

* Cancer of Ovary

* http://wiki-medical.org/hormones_dysox.htm

* http://wiki-medical.org/oxygen_liver.htm

* Pelvic Examination - How Helpful? How Harmful?

 

 

 

 

 

 

Welcome  

Who Is Dr. Ali?

Dr. Ali's Full CV

Peer Reviews of Dr. Ali' Work

 

Dr. Ali's Philosophy

 
 

 

VIDEO Courses

Philosophy of Integrative medicine 

Dr. Ali's Recent Videos

Click here to order Prof. Ali's Video Courses, digital aand print books, DVD seminars, and lectures on CD sets.

 

Now Available as
Instant Download

Integrative Protocols -
Vol 12 Principles and Practices
of Integrative Medicine

Includes
Dr. Ali's
IV and IM formulations

E-Book 12



Integrative Protocols -
Vol 11 Principles and Practices
of Integrative Medicine
E-Book 11


Dr. Ali discusses Dysoxygenosis and varying chronic diseases.

NEW BOOK!

Book Diabetes

OR
Instant Download